Church Period: Lent 3rd Wednesday
Sermon Title: A Substitute For Us
Sermon Date: March 6, 1969
Rev. August Hauptman
Sermon Text: Matthew 26:59-68
Dear Christian friends:
About one year ago here in Minneapolis a young man appeared
in court and pleaded guilty to a crime which he did not
commit, and the judge sentenced him to ninety days in the
workhouse. Two weeks later the officer at the workhouse
found out that he was the wrong man.
When officers questioned him, he confessed that he was a
friend of the guilty man. He told the officers that he had
no job, but his friend had a good job, so he agreed to go
to court and the workhouse in place of his friend. He agreed
to be condemned and suffer the shame and punishment for his
friend, and almost succeeded.
Things like this have happened before. In the story, "A Tale
of Two Cities" by Charles Dickens, a man exchanged places
with his friend while visiting him in prison. The friend
escaped free, but that man lost his head the next day on the
guillotine.
In a more wonderful way Jesus volunteered to go to court for
us and be condemned. Tonight as we continue to study, The
Places In His Passion, we go with Jesus to the palace of the
High Priest and watch while He is condemned.
After praying in the Garden of Gethsemane Jesus was arrested
by a mob led by Judas. They bound Jesus and led Him to the
palace of the High Priest, Caiaphas. The palace was very
large with many apartments. Caiaphas' father-in-law lived
in one apartment. While Caiaphas lived in another. Annas
before ruled as High Priest and still was honored by that
name although he now was not in office, as we still call
Truman and Eisenhower, "President." The palace also had
other apartments for servants and soldiers.
One of the main rooms of the palace was the courtroom where
the High Priest sat with the seventy members of Sanhedrin,
("Council"). Here they made church laws and answered questions
concerning them. They also judged those who were accused with
breaking of the law and decided on the punishment.
It was about midnight or later when the mob of soldiers
brought Jesus to the palace of the High Priest, already
Friday morning. It seems that many of the council members
had not yet arrived. Since the meeting was not planned and
since it was a very unusual hour to call a meeting, 1:00 am
many members of the council were still sleeping and had to
be aroused, get dressed and walk from their homes to the
palace.
While they were waiting for all the members to assemble
they decided to let Annas, the retired high priest
question Jesus to see if He could catch Jesus saying
something wrong. But Jesus did not fall into his trap.
When he questioned Jesus about His teaching Jesus answered,
"I taught openly to the people. I said nothing in secret.
Why do you ask Me? Ask those who heard Me. They know what
I said." Then one of the servants slapped Jesus' face saying,
"Is that how you answer the High Priest?" Jesus wisely
replied, "If I said something wrong prove it. But if I have
told the truth, why do you hit Me?" So Annas gave up and
sent Jesus to Caiaphas in the courtroom.
Now the council had gathered. And we read in our text that
they tried to get false testimony against Jesus in order to
kill Him, but didn't find any.
When the High Priest saw that the witnesses did not agree
that He could prove anything wrong in Jesus He gave up
trying to find witnesses, and like Annas his father-in-law
tried to tempt Jesus to talk. But Jesus was silent. Finally,
the High Priest asked Jesus, "Are you the promised Savior,
the Son of God? Jesus could not remain silent any longer
He answered, "I am," and then He added, "one day you will
see me coming in the clouds of heaven to judge you."
Then the High Priest tore his robes and declared, "He has
blasphemed, you just heard the blasphemy (lies). What's
your verdict?" They answered, "He must die."
So we see Jesus standing in court and condemned to die.
They say He has blasphemed. Blasphemy means to lie about
God's Word. Jesus taught and swore that He was the promised
Savior the Son of God. He even said He would come on the
last day to judge all people.
We believe that Jesus is the Son of God and the promised
Savior. We know that Jesus did not lie, did not blaspheme
and mock God and His church. But the High Priest and the
council did no believe Jesus so they condemned Him as a
liar. They said, "He must die!"
Yes, Jesus must die! Yes, Jesus is guilty. He is a sinner
now. Why? Not because of the lies the Jews bring against
Him, but because He has accepted our sins, and the sins of
all people. We have sinned and should go to court before
the judge of all, God. God judges all of us and finds us
guilty: "for all have sinned and fall short of the glory
of God," (Romans 3:23) “There is none righteous, not
even one;" (Romans 3:10) And what is His verdict?
Death, "The soul that sinneth, it shall die." (Ezekiel 18:4)
Separated from the holy God forever.
That is why Jesus meekly stands in the court of the High
Priest. He is standing there because of us. He is everything
they say He is even a blasphemer because we have mocked God
and often thought His holy things cheap and worthless. We
often prefer bread and butter.
Jesus is guilty because we are guilty. He must die as the
court decides, because we deserve to die.
We find great comfort and hope in this sad and terrible
story: Because Jesus went to court, we do not have to go
there. Because He was condemned by God, we do not have to
hear those terrible words: "Depart from Me, ye cursed,
into everlasting fire." (Matthew 25:41)
As we watch Jesus here in the court accept the shame and
blame of our sins, we grow in love and praise to Him
because He loved us like that. We can't every repay Him
for this great love and kindness, but we can love and
give thanks to Him by serving Him and by loving one another
more. Surely, we can see how rotten and terrible sin is,
and so with His love and power we will try to avoid
sinning, jealousy, selfishness and falsely condemning
others. We will try to put God first in our thinking and
doing and work to spread His Kingdom of grace and truth
here in this sinful world.
Amen.